Historic Sites

The Wayne County Historic Sites project was designed to document locations of interest to historians, genealogists, and those interested in local history. MOST sites are on PRIVATE PROPERTY and therefore are NOT OPEN TO THE PUBLIC. If you wish to view sites on private property, you MUST do so from PUBLIC STREETS ONLY. Only the owner of record may authorize you to enter private property. PLEASE RESPECT PRIVATE PROPERTY OWNER RIGHTS.

Local historians have selected sites for this project based on a variety of criteria. Some sites may have been chosen based on local interest and not necessarily on rigid historical standards. The goal of the Wayne County Historic Sites project is to provide accurate information about each site. We realize mistakes occur and we may not have as much information as some would like. We encourage YOU to contact us at contact@waynehistorians.org with additional information OR notify us about any errors.

Cecilia B. Jackson was appointed Town of Arcadia Historian in July 1968. She moved to Newark when her father, A. Eugene Bolles, bought the Newark Courier in 1924. 'Historic Homes' is not only a story of old homes that are over 100 years old, but the stories of the people who lived in them.

Sites Found: 79
Site #ExistsSite NameAddressTown
CJ-001YesHistoric Marker - Site of Joseph Miller's homeWest Miller StreetArcadia
CJ-002GoneCobblestone house (destroyed)312 West Miller St. Newark NYArcadia
CJ-003GoneDr. Cyrus Button Farmhouse, later Allerton320 South Main St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-004GoneO.H. Allerton Mansion233 South Main St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-005YesAllerton - Radder - Flanagan House101 Highland Ave, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-006YesKeller-Stuart Cobblestone House513 W. Maple Ave. Newark NYArcadia
CJ-007YesTillotson - Ryckbost887 Hanley Rd, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-008YesPrescott - Sirkin - Blodgett308 East Maple Av, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-009YesCobblestone house3134 Hanagan Rd Palmyra NYPalmyra
CJ-010YesA.C. Bartle - DeLeo201 Scott St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-011YesAvery Cobblestone3049 Parker Rd. Palmyra NYPalmyra
CJ-012YesHamer - Capwell304 Vienna St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-013YesTurkey Hollow3014 Leroy Rd, Palmyra NYPalmyra
CJ-014YesAbner Burley Place6751 Old Lyons Rd, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-015YesHoeltzel - Espenmiller - Werts321 West Ave, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-016YesElias Durfee Cut Stone home3828 Walworth-Marion Road, Marion, NYMarion
CJ-017YesThe Thomas House103 Jefferson St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-018YesCobblestone house3353 Daansen Rd, Walworth, NYWalworth
CJ-019YesPrice - Vanderbrook137 Williams St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-020YesDurfee - Smith1945 Walworth Road, Palmyra, NYMacedon
CJ-021YesGifford - Hoover Farm660 Marbletown Rd, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-022YesPalmer - Scofield - DeMay990 Palmer Rd, Palmyra NYPalmyra
CJ-023YesSteight House402 East Ave, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-024YesKelley - Wagner303 Vienna Rd, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-025YesDAR Chapter House119 High St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-026YesJackson and Perkins Estate (Vintage Gardens B&B)310 High St., Newark, NYArcadia
CJ-027YesBenton - Pulver817 North Main St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-028YesMansard style 1810 Hydesville Road (Co Rd 221), Newark NYArcadia
CJ-029YesSwift - Wege1570 Walworth Road, Palmyra, NYMacedon
CJ-030YesBartle - Millbrook118 West Maple Ave, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-031YesHunt - Benzie - Robinson736 North Main St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-032YesCobblestone house301 Silver Hill Rd. Newark NYArcadia
CJ-033YesPresbyterian Manse - Parker113 Williams St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-034YesJuffs - Smith3046 Route 88 North, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-035YesThe Bauer Place242 East Miller St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-036YesReeves - MacLaren1793 Hydesville Rd, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-037YesCrothers - Colacino217 Church St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-038YesWelcher - Wells Farm3391 Fairville Maple Ridge Rd, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-039YesIglesia de Dios Pentecostal315 East Miller St. Newark NYArcadia
CJ-040YesSauers - Storm2744 Route 88 North, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-041GoneMarion
CJ-042YesPrice - Avery1343 Hillside Dr, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-043YesVan Wickle - Hemingway7481 Bauer Van Wickle Rd, Lyons NYLyons
CJ-044YesCronise - Taylor - Parcero417 Vienna Rd, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-045YesThe Purchase House215 Colton Ave, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-046YesSilver Hill Farm207 Vienna Rd, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-047YesHardy - Munneke - Deven4469 North Creek Rd, Palmyra NYPalmyra
CJ-048YesLamoreaux - Olmsted402 East Union St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-049YesLee Cobblestone house2659 Minsteed Rd., Newark NYArcadia
CJ-050YesJohnson - Boogaard11921 West Main St, Wolcott NYWolcott
CJ-051YesPaul Jagger Cobblestone3142 Lyon Rd., Marion, NY Palmyra
CJ-052YesGardner - Finch117 Franklin St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-053YesPetty - Westfall - Hallagan508 East Ave, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-054YesScott - Bailey - Fremouw528 East Ave, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-055YesParsons - Colacino503 South Main St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-056YesCressy - Maressa120 West Miller St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-057YesGreek Revival322 Vienna Street, Newark, NYArcadia
CJ-058YesPalmer - Springett110 Jefferson St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-059YesMuth Cobblestone house240 West Pearl St.Arcadia
CJ-060YesParker Cobblestone house2467 Parker Rd Newark NYArcadia
CJ-061YesWebb - Howard - Li Farm4346 Route 88 North, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-062YesKeener - Morse (Wolf's Tea Room)412 East Ave, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-063YesWhitbeck - Frey Farm2227 Route 88 North, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-064YesHowell - Mander3637 DeNeering Rd, Marion NYMarion
CJ-065YesCoventry - Reed - Schulz Funeral Home103 Maple Court, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-066YesFisk - Ackerson246 East Miller St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-067YesStuart - Graybill608 North Main St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-068YesButler - Lagenor125 East Pearl St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-069YesCobblestone house107 Maple Court Newark NYArcadia
CJ-070YesClark Cobblestone4698 South Creek Rd Palmyra NYPalmyra
CJ-071YesBlackmar - Holdridge129 Williams St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-072YesHumphrey Shearman's Inn4839 Tellier Rd, East Palmyra NYPalmyra
CJ-073YesPulver - Norris Farm6943 Sodus Center Rd, Sodus NYSodus
CJ-074YesNicholoy - Justino120 Grant St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-075YesPiper - Doebler Office614 South Main St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-076YesKrabbenschmidt - Codde - Pryzbyc230 Prospect St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-077YesPomeroy - Pellicano205 Jefferson St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-078YesPitts - Scott Funeral Home124 West Miller St, Newark NYArcadia
CJ-079YesPeirson - Hyde - Welcher Farm1871 Parker Rd, Newark NYArcadia